Skip to content
Tax & CRA

Salary vs. Dividends for Alberta Owner-Managers: How to Actually Decide

The most common question incorporated business owners ask, and the one with the most confidently wrong answers online. The seven factors that actually determine it.

Phil Krahn, B.Com.

Founder & Principal

6 min read
Tax & CRA

Salary vs. Dividends for Alberta Owner-Managers: How to Actually Decide

Search this question and you will find a great deal of confident advice. Much of it is wrong, and nearly all of it is wrong in the same way: it answers as though there were one answer.

There is not. The right mix depends on at least seven variables, and it changes as your circumstances change. Here is how to think about it properly.

The theory: integration

Canadian tax is built around a principle called integration. In theory, income earned through a corporation and paid out as dividends should attract roughly the same total tax as income earned personally — the corporate tax plus the personal dividend tax should approximate the personal rate you would have paid directly.

Integration is not perfect. Depending on the province, the income level, and the type of dividend, there are small advantages one way or the other. But those differences are usually smaller than people expect, and they are rarely what should drive the decision.

The implication that matters: if you are taking all the money out of the company each year, salary and dividends produce broadly similar outcomes. The interesting factors are the non-tax ones below.

The seven factors

1. Are you leaving money in the company?

The most important question.

Salary is deductible to the corporation. Dividends are not — they are paid from after-tax profit.

If profit is staying in the company, dividends let you leave it there taxed only at the small business rate, which is substantially lower than personal rates at higher incomes. That deferral is the single largest advantage of incorporating, and dividends are how you access it.

If everything is coming out annually, this factor is neutral.

2. Do you want RRSP contribution room?

Only salary creates RRSP room. Dividends create none.

RRSP room accrues at 18% of earned income up to an annual maximum. If you want to contribute meaningfully, you need salary — enough of it to generate the room you intend to use.

Whether that matters depends on whether you would rather build retirement savings inside your RRSP or inside your corporation. Both are legitimate strategies, and reasonable advisors disagree about which is better.

3. Do you want CPP?

Salary attracts CPP contributions, at both the employee and employer rate — so as an owner-manager you pay both halves. That is a real cost.

The counterargument is that CPP is an inflation-indexed lifetime benefit backed by the federal government, and the return on contributions is not bad when viewed as insurance against outliving your savings rather than as an investment.

Dividends attract no CPP. Some owner-managers treat that as a saving; others treat it as forgone retirement income. There is no objectively correct answer, and it depends substantially on your age and your other retirement provision.

4. Your personal marginal rate

Alberta's combined rates are progressive across several brackets. The mix should be assessed against where you sit in that scale, not against an average.

If your income is at a level where an additional dollar is taxed at the top rate, the calculation differs meaningfully from someone in the lowest bracket. Do the arithmetic on your actual number.

5. Passive investment income in the corporation

For a CCPC, passive investment income above a threshold begins grinding down the small business deduction, and above a higher threshold eliminates it entirely.

If your corporation holds a substantial investment portfolio, the interaction between passive income and the SBD may argue for taking more out personally rather than accumulating further inside the company. This is one of the more consequential factors and one of the most frequently ignored.

6. Cash flow and timing

Salary requires payroll: regular remittances, source deductions, T4s at year end. It is administratively heavier but it spreads the tax across the year.

Dividends are simpler administratively — a directors' resolution and a T5 — but the tax lands with your personal return, which means you need to manage instalments or reserve for a single larger payment.

For businesses with lumpy cash flow, that difference is practical rather than theoretical.

7. Other benefits tied to employment income

Several things key off employment income specifically:

  • Childcare expense deductions require earned income
  • Some mortgage lenders treat T4 income more favourably than dividend income, though this varies considerably by lender
  • Disability and critical illness coverage amounts are often calculated on employment income
  • EI is generally not available to owner-managers with significant control, so this rarely factors in

The mortgage point catches people out. If you are planning to borrow within a couple of years, talk to a broker about how they will treat your income before you set your compensation structure. Some lenders will gross up dividend income; others will not.

The blended approach

In practice, most owner-managers take some of each, and there are two common structures.

Salary to a target, dividends above it. Take enough salary to generate the RRSP room you want, then dividends for the rest. This is the most common approach we implement.

Salary to the small business limit, dividends above. Where profit exceeds the small business limit, paying salary to bring corporate income down to the limit avoids the general corporate rate on the excess.

Both are starting points, not prescriptions.

What to avoid

Doing what you did last year without checking. Circumstances change. A year with a large capital gain, a year you buy a house, a year profit doubles — each changes the answer.

Taking money without characterising it. Drawing cash and deciding later what it was is how shareholder loan problems begin. A shareholder loan generally has to be repaid within one year of the end of the fiscal year in which it arose, or the full amount can be included in your personal income.

Ignoring the paperwork. Salary needs payroll registration, remittances, and T4s. Dividends need a directors' resolution and a T5. Neither is optional, and CRA does look at whether the formalities were followed.

Applying advice written for another province. Provincial rates differ enough that a calculation done for Ontario or BC does not transfer to Alberta.

How we approach it

We model both against your actual numbers — corporate profit, personal marginal rate, RRSP room, whether money is staying in the company, and what you are planning over the next two or three years.

The output is a recommendation with the arithmetic attached, so you can see why, not just what. In our experience the difference between a well-chosen mix and a default one is meaningful, but rarely dramatic — and the non-tax factors, particularly RRSP room and CPP, often matter more than the tax itself.

To have it modelled properly, book a free consultation or call (403) 700-9434.

salary vs dividendsowner-managercorporate taxRRSPCPP

Phil Krahn, B.Com.

Founder & Principal

25+ years in finance, from night auditor to VP Finance to founding Big Country Accounting Group. Serving businesses and families across Alberta, Saskatchewan, and British Columbia.

Questions about your own situation?

General writing only goes so far. Thirty minutes on the phone is free, and you will get a straight answer about your actual circumstances.

All articles

Related reading

CallFree consultation