DIY vs. Professional Tax Prep: How Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC Filers Can Choose the Right Path
Tax software is very good at arithmetic and very bad at judgement. An honest look at when doing it yourself is the right call — and the six situations where it reliably is not.
Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
DIY vs. Professional Tax Prep: How Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC Filers Can Choose the Right Path
An accounting firm publishing a comparison of DIY versus professional tax preparation has an obvious conflict of interest. So let me start with the part against interest:
If your return is simple, use the software. One T4, standard deductions, no self-employment, no rental, no investments beyond a TFSA. The software will do it correctly in forty minutes for under fifty dollars, and paying someone several hundred to do the same thing is a waste of your money.
Roughly half the population is in that category, and the honest answer for them is: do it yourself.
Here is where that stops being true.
What tax software does well
Genuinely well, and worth acknowledging:
- Arithmetic. It does not make calculation errors.
- Slip import. Auto-fill My Return pulls your T4s, T5s, and other slips directly from CRA.
- Standard credits. Basic personal amount, CPP and EI, tuition, medical — it handles the mechanics correctly.
- Netfile. Straight through to CRA with immediate confirmation.
- Cost. Free to about $50 for most personal returns.
What it does not do
This is the whole distinction, and it is not about calculation.
It does not ask questions it was not programmed to ask. It will not enquire whether your spouse should be claiming the medical expenses instead of you, whether this is the year to trigger a capital loss, or whether the home office proportion you have entered would survive a review.
It does not know your other years. Tax planning is multi-year. Software optimises the return in front of it — which is sometimes precisely the wrong thing. Claiming the maximum CCA on a rental property lowers this year's tax and creates a recapture problem on sale that can be considerably larger.
It accepts what you tell it. Enter a home office at 40% of your house and it will happily calculate the deduction. It will not mention that 40% is aggressive and this is one of the most reviewed claims in Canada.
It does not know what you failed to mention. It cannot ask about the foreign account, the crypto disposals, or the fact you changed the use of a property.
It will not defend the return. When CRA writes, you are on your own.
Six situations where DIY reliably goes wrong
1. Self-employment or business income
The T2125 is where most DIY returns go astray — not through fraud, but through not knowing what is claimable.
Home office proportion, vehicle expenses and the mileage log, CCA class selection, the current-expense-versus-capital line, the business-use portion of a phone, and the CPP calculation on self-employment income that surprises nearly everyone in their first full year.
We routinely find several thousand dollars of legitimate missed deductions in self-employed returns that were prepared carefully by intelligent people.
2. Rental property
The CCA decision alone justifies a conversation. Claiming it reduces tax now and creates recapture on sale — potentially a much larger bill later, at a moment when you may also have a capital gain.
Add the current expense versus capital improvement distinction (the line CRA tests most), change-of-use rules, and the principal residence exemption where a property has been both, and this is not a checkbox exercise.
3. Investments beyond registered accounts
Adjusted cost base tracking, superficial loss rules, foreign property reporting on the T1135 where holdings exceed $100,000 CAD, and the taxation of foreign dividends.
The T1135 in particular has a substantial penalty for non-filing and applies more broadly than people expect — it captures foreign-held securities, not only offshore bank accounts.
4. Multiple provinces, or a move
Provincial tax is determined by where you were resident on December 31. A move mid-year, work in a different province from where you live, or the year you left or entered Canada all raise questions software handles poorly.
5. A significant life change
Marriage or separation, a death in the family, a first home purchase, retirement, or a large one-time gain. These are the years where planning affects the outcome most and where the software's inability to look across returns costs the most.
6. Several years unfiled
Do not attempt this alone. There are ordering considerations, the Voluntary Disclosures Program may substantially reduce penalties, and how you approach CRA matters. Coming forward properly is materially better than filing five years of returns and waiting.
The middle option people forget
You do not have to choose permanently.
Have it done professionally once, in a year where something changed — you started a business, bought a rental, had an unusual event. Then use that return as a template for the following simpler years.
You get the judgement applied where it mattered, and you are not paying for it annually when nothing has changed. We suggest this to people regularly and it is often the right answer.
What a preparer should actually be doing
If you engage someone, you should be getting more than data entry. A preparer earning their fee will:
- Ask about next year, not just this one
- Compare claims across spouses to optimise the household, not the individual
- Flag anything aggressive before filing and explain the exposure
- Explain the Notice of Assessment when it arrives
- Be there if CRA writes
If your current preparer takes an envelope and returns a completed form with no conversation, you are paying professional rates for software-equivalent output.
Cost, plainly
- DIY: free to around $50
- Simple professional return: a few hundred dollars
- Self-employed or rental: more, depending on complexity
- Multi-year catch-up: quoted after seeing what is involved
For a straightforward return, DIY wins clearly. For anything in the six categories above, the fee is routinely less than what is recovered — and considerably less than the cost of a claim that does not hold up.
The summary
Simple return: use the software, and do not let anyone tell you otherwise.
Business income, rental property, investments, a life change, a move, or unfiled years: get help. Not because the arithmetic is hard, but because the judgement is where the money is.
Unsure which side you are on? Ask us or call (403) 700-9434. If the answer is "you're fine doing this yourself," that is what you will hear.

Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
25+ years in finance, from night auditor to VP Finance to founding Big Country Accounting Group. Serving businesses and families across Alberta, Saskatchewan, and British Columbia.
Questions about your own situation?
General writing only goes so far. Thirty minutes on the phone is free, and you will get a straight answer about your actual circumstances.
