Payroll Pitfalls in Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC — And How to Avoid Them
Payroll is the one area where being a day late is immediately expensive. The eight mistakes we see most often in Western Canadian small businesses, and what each one actually costs.
Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
PayrollPayroll is unforgiving in a way most compliance is not. A late GST return is a problem you can usually sort out. A late payroll remittance is a penalty applied automatically, calculated as a percentage of the amount, on the day it is late.
That is because source deductions are held in trust. The money was never the company's — it belongs to the employee and to CRA. The rules reflect that, and directors can be held personally liable for unremitted amounts even in a corporation.
Here are the mistakes that cause the most trouble.
1. Missing a remittance deadline
Regular remitters pay by the 15th of the month following the deductions. Quarterly, accelerated, and threshold-2 remitters run on different schedules that CRA assigns based on your withholding history.
Penalties apply on a sliding scale depending on how late the payment is, and repeated lateness within the same year attracts a substantially higher rate. There is no grace period and no minimum.
Avoid it: set the remittance up as a recurring calendar item with a reminder several days before, not on the day. If cash is tight, remit the source deductions before anything else — this is genuinely the last bill you should ever be late on.
2. Getting your remitter type wrong
CRA reassesses your remitter classification periodically based on average monthly withholding. Growth moves you from quarterly to regular, and from regular to accelerated — and accelerated deadlines are dramatically tighter, sometimes within a few days of the pay date.
Avoid it: open the notices CRA sends about remitter type, and check your classification each January. A business that grew last year is the classic case of remitting on the old schedule and being late without realising.
3. Misclassifying employees as contractors
The most expensive mistake on this list, and the most common.
Calling someone a contractor does not make them one. CRA and the courts look at the substance: control over how and when the work is done, who owns the tools, whether there is a real chance of profit or risk of loss, and how integrated the person is into the business.
If CRA reclassifies a contractor as an employee, the company becomes liable for both the employer and employee portions of CPP and EI, plus interest and penalties, potentially across several years.
Avoid it: if someone works set hours, uses your equipment, takes direction on method, and works only for you, they are very likely an employee regardless of what the agreement says. Where it is genuinely borderline, you can request a CPP/EI ruling from CRA — a determination in advance is far better than one made retrospectively.
4. Missing taxable benefits
The ones most often forgotten:
- Personal use of a company vehicle — both the standby charge and the operating benefit
- Gifts and awards above the CRA thresholds
- Employer-paid group life insurance premiums
- Parking, where taxable in your circumstances
- Cell phones and internet where personal use is significant
- Health spending account amounts, depending on structure
Each of these belongs on the T4 and generally attracts CPP, and sometimes EI. Discovering them in February means amended slips, a corrected remittance, and an employee whose tax outcome just changed.
Avoid it: review benefits quarterly rather than annually. It is a fifteen-minute exercise that prevents a genuinely awkward conversation.
5. Provincial employment standards differences
If you operate across Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC, the payroll calculation is not the same in each. Statutory holidays differ. Overtime thresholds differ — Alberta uses 8 hours a day and 44 a week; other provinces use different combinations. Vacation entitlement escalates on different schedules. General holiday pay is calculated differently.
Avoid it: if you have staff in more than one province, confirm the rules for each rather than applying your home province's. A payroll system configured once for Alberta will quietly get BC wrong for years.
6. Late or missing Records of Employment
An ROE is generally required within five calendar days of the end of the pay period in which an interruption of earnings occurs, when filing electronically. Paper filing has a different deadline.
A late ROE delays your former employee's EI claim, which is both a compliance problem and a human one — this is somebody who has just lost their income.
Avoid it: make the ROE part of your offboarding checklist, filed at the same time as the final pay, not weeks later.
7. T4 errors and the February deadline
T4s must be filed with CRA and distributed to employees by the last day of February. Late filing carries a per-slip penalty that scales with the number of slips, so headcount magnifies the cost of being a week late.
The most common errors: wrong or missing SINs, taxable benefits omitted, boxes 16/18/22 not reconciling to what was actually remitted, and employment income reported in the wrong year for a pay period spanning December 31.
Avoid it: reconcile payroll to the general ledger and to your CRA account in January. Every problem you find in January is small; the same problem found on February 26 is not.
8. Paying a bonus without withholding
Bonuses are employment income. They attract income tax, CPP, and usually EI, and CRA has specific bonus tax methods for calculating the withholding.
Paying a $5,000 bonus as a round $5,000 transfer with no deductions creates a shortfall that surfaces at year end — at which point you either gross it up at company cost or have an unpleasant conversation with an employee about the tax bill they were not expecting.
Avoid it: run bonuses through payroll. Always. Including your own.
The underlying pattern
Almost every item here is a calendar problem or a classification problem. Neither is difficult — both are simply easy to lose track of when payroll is the thing you do at the end of a long day.
That is precisely why it is worth handing off. Not because it is complicated, but because it is unforgiving of the ordinary human tendency to be busy.
If payroll is currently a source of low-grade anxiety, let us take it or call (403) 700-9434. We run the cycle, calculate the deductions, file the remittance, and keep the calendar — whether you have two employees or forty-five.

Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
25+ years in finance, from night auditor to VP Finance to founding Big Country Accounting Group. Serving businesses and families across Alberta, Saskatchewan, and British Columbia.
Questions about your own situation?
General writing only goes so far. Thirty minutes on the phone is free, and you will get a straight answer about your actual circumstances.