Inventory Valuation Methods Explained: A Practical Guide for Western Canadian Businesses
FIFO, weighted average, and why LIFO is not permitted in Canada — plus the lower of cost and net realisable value rule that catches businesses holding ageing stock.
Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
BookkeepingInventory sits on your balance sheet as an asset and flows through your income statement as cost of goods sold. Get the valuation wrong and both your profit and your tax bill are wrong — in one direction or the other.
For a business holding meaningful stock this is not a technicality. Inventory is frequently the largest current asset on the balance sheet.
The two methods used in Canada
FIFO — first in, first out
Assumes the oldest inventory sells first. Remaining inventory is valued at the most recent purchase costs.
Example. You buy 100 units at $10, then 100 units at $12. You sell 150.
- COGS = (100 × $10) + (50 × $12) = $1,600
- Closing inventory = 50 × $12 = $600
Advantages: it matches how most businesses physically operate, particularly with perishable or dated goods; the balance sheet reflects current replacement cost; it is the most widely used and understood.
Consideration: in a period of rising prices, FIFO produces lower COGS and therefore higher reported profit — and higher tax.
Weighted average cost
Averages the cost of all units available.
Same example: 200 units costing $2,200 total, so $11 per unit.
- COGS = 150 × $11 = $1,650
- Closing inventory = 50 × $11 = $550
Advantages: simpler with high volumes of interchangeable items; smooths out price volatility; less sensitive to purchase timing.
Best for: commodities, bulk materials, fuel, and anything where units are genuinely indistinguishable.
Specific identification
Each item tracked individually at its actual cost. Required in practice for high-value, distinguishable items: vehicles, heavy equipment, jewellery, art.
LIFO is not permitted in Canada
Worth stating clearly, because American accounting content is everywhere and LIFO is common in the US.
Last in, first out is not acceptable for Canadian tax purposes or under IFRS. If you have read about LIFO's tax advantages in a US source, they do not apply here.
The rule that catches people: lower of cost and net realisable value
Regardless of which method you use, inventory must generally be carried at the lower of cost and net realisable value — NRV being the estimated selling price less the costs to complete and sell it.
This matters when stock has:
- Become obsolete or superseded
- Been damaged
- Fallen in market price below what you paid
- Aged past the point where it will sell at full price
If you paid $50 for a unit you can now realistically sell for $30, it belongs on the balance sheet at $30. The $20 difference is a write-down that hits this year's profit.
Businesses resist this, understandably — it reduces reported profit and reduces the asset base a lender looks at. But carrying obsolete stock at cost overstates both your assets and your profit, which means every decision you make from those numbers is made on a false picture. It also means the reckoning arrives later and larger.
In practice: review inventory ageing at least annually, at year end. Anything that has not moved in twelve months deserves a hard look.
Consistency is the rule that matters most
You must apply your method consistently year to year. CRA does not permit switching methods to manage taxable income.
Changing methods requires a genuine business reason and generally needs disclosure. If you have inherited an inconsistently applied approach, sort it out deliberately with advice rather than quietly.
Periodic versus perpetual
Separate from valuation method: how you track quantity.
Periodic — you count physically at period end and derive COGS from the movement. Cheaper and simpler, but you have no visibility between counts and shrinkage is invisible until the count.
Perpetual — every movement updates the record continuously. Requires a system, gives real-time visibility, and makes shrinkage detectable because you can compare the system quantity to a physical count.
Even with perpetual, count physically at least annually. The system tells you what should be there. Only a count tells you what is. The gap is shrinkage — theft, damage, miscounts, unrecorded returns — and for retail it is frequently 1–2% of sales, which is a large share of net margin.
What actually goes into "cost"
More than the invoice price. Cost generally includes everything to bring the item to its present location and condition:
- Purchase price, net of trade discounts
- Freight and shipping in
- Duties and non-recoverable taxes
- Handling costs to get it into stock
For manufacturers, also direct materials, direct labour, and a systematic allocation of production overhead.
Not included: selling costs, general administrative overhead, storage of finished goods, or abnormal waste.
Businesses that omit freight-in from cost understate inventory and overstate current-period expense. It is a common error and worth checking.
Where it bites in practice
Retail — shrinkage and seasonal obsolescence. Count regularly and mark down promptly. Stock that did not sell last season rarely sells at full price this one.
Construction and trades — materials on site are inventory or work in progress, not immediate expense. Year-end material on uncompleted jobs frequently gets expensed when it should be capitalised, which understates both profit and assets.
Restaurants — high turnover, high spoilage. Weekly counts on key items are standard practice for a reason; food cost percentage is meaningless without accurate inventory.
Manufacturing — the most complex, because you have raw materials, work in progress, and finished goods, plus overhead allocation. This is the case where investing in proper systems genuinely pays for itself.
The practical summary
- Choose FIFO or weighted average, and apply it consistently
- LIFO is not available in Canada
- Write down to net realisable value when stock will not sell at cost
- Count physically at least annually, more often if shrinkage is a risk
- Include freight and duties in cost
- Review inventory ageing as part of every year end
If inventory is a material part of your balance sheet and you are not confident it is being handled properly, get in touch or call (403) 700-9434. It is worth getting right — it affects your profit, your tax, and what your lender sees.

Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
25+ years in finance, from night auditor to VP Finance to founding Big Country Accounting Group. Serving businesses and families across Alberta, Saskatchewan, and British Columbia.
Questions about your own situation?
General writing only goes so far. Thirty minutes on the phone is free, and you will get a straight answer about your actual circumstances.
