Incorporation vs. Sole Proprietorship: How Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC Owners Should Decide
Incorporating is not automatically the right move. The four questions that actually determine the answer, and the ongoing costs nobody mentions until you are already committed.
Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
Incorporation vs. Sole Proprietorship: How Alberta, Saskatchewan, and BC Owners Should Decide
Plenty of people will tell you to incorporate. Some of them are selling incorporation services.
The honest answer is that it depends on four things, and for a meaningful share of small businesses the answer is "not yet."
The four questions
1. Is profit staying in the company?
This is the big one, and it is where most of the tax benefit lives.
Incorporating provides a tax deferral, not a tax elimination. Profit left in the company is taxed at the small business rate, which is substantially lower than personal rates at higher income levels. But when you take that money out personally, you pay tax again on the dividend.
The benefit is real only if the money stays in — funding growth, building a reserve, or investing.
If you earn $90,000 and spend all $90,000 on your household, incorporating changes very little on tax while adding cost and compliance. If you earn $200,000 and live on $110,000, the $90,000 remaining in the company is deferring tax meaningfully.
2. Is liability a genuine risk?
A corporation is a separate legal person. Its debts are generally its own.
That protection is real but narrower than people assume:
- Banks will almost always require a personal guarantee from the owner of a small corporation, which removes the protection on the largest debt
- Directors are personally liable for unremitted source deductions and GST, regardless of incorporation
- You remain liable for your own negligence; incorporation does not shield professional error
- Piercing the corporate veil is possible where the separation was not respected in practice
Where it matters most: physical risk from your operations, contractual exposure on large projects, and employing people.
3. Does a client require it?
Increasingly common, and a perfectly good reason on its own.
Many general contractors and larger organisations will not engage an unincorporated individual, partly because of the personal services business and employee-classification risk on their side. If incorporating is the price of the contract, the analysis is simple.
4. Are you planning to sell?
The lifetime capital gains exemption on qualifying small business corporation shares can shelter a substantial gain on sale — an amount large enough to dominate every other consideration if a sale is realistic.
There are qualification tests around asset composition and holding period, and meeting them typically requires planning years ahead. If a sale is on the horizon, this is worth discussing early.
The costs nobody mentions upfront
Incorporation has an annual compliance load, and this is where the "just incorporate" advice usually falls down.
Setup: government filing fees, NUANS name search, and professional fees for share structure, bylaws, and minute book. Doable cheaply online — but the share structure is the part worth paying for, and the part most expensive to fix later.
Every year afterwards:
- Corporate T2 return — required even with no income
- Financial statement compilation, typically expected by lenders
- Alberta annual return with Corporate Registry
- Minute book maintenance — annual resolutions and minutes
- Separate bank accounts and bookkeeping
- [Payroll](/services/bookkeeping-payroll) or dividend administration for your own compensation
Realistically the annual professional cost of a corporation is materially higher than a sole proprietorship. That difference is the hurdle the tax benefit has to clear.
Sole proprietorship: the case for it
It gets dismissed too quickly.
Simplicity. Business income goes on your personal T1. One return, one filing, one set of books.
Losses offset personal income. This is genuinely valuable in early years. A startup loss in a sole proprietorship can offset employment income from a job you still hold. In a corporation, that loss is trapped inside the company until it has profit to absorb it.
Lower cost, materially.
You can incorporate later. Section 85 of the Income Tax Act allows a tax-deferred rollover of a sole proprietorship into a corporation. Starting unincorporated does not close the door.
That last point is underrated. Many businesses should start as a sole proprietorship, absorb the early losses personally, then incorporate once profitable.
A practical rule of thumb
Stay a sole proprietor when:
- Profit is under roughly $80,000–$100,000 and you are spending most of it
- You are in the first year or two and may make losses
- Liability risk is low
- No client requires incorporation
Incorporate when:
- Profit consistently exceeds what you need to draw personally
- You are retaining earnings for growth or investment
- Liability risk is genuine
- A client requires it
- You are building something you intend to sell
And model it properly when you are close to the line, because the answer depends on your specific numbers rather than a threshold.
A word on partnerships
A general partnership is a sole proprietorship with more people and, usually, more risk. Each partner is jointly and severally liable for the partnership's obligations — including those created by the other partner without your knowledge.
If you are going into business with someone, a corporation with a proper shareholders' agreement is nearly always the better structure. The agreement matters as much as the incorporation: what happens if one of you wants out, dies, becomes disabled, or stops contributing.
Getting the structure right the first time
If you do incorporate, the decisions worth care are:
- Share classes — who holds what, and whether family members should hold shares
- Federal versus provincial — provincial is cheaper and sufficient for most Alberta businesses
- Fiscal year end — not required to be December 31, and there is sometimes an advantage in choosing otherwise
- Whether a holding company belongs in the picture, now or later
All of these are fixable afterwards, and all of them are several times more expensive to fix than to get right at the start.
The honest summary
Incorporating is a business decision with a tax dimension, not a tax decision. If the only reason is "everyone says you should," that is not a reason.
If you would like the numbers run on your actual situation, book a free consultation or call (403) 700-9434. We will tell you when the answer is no — it has cost us work before, and it is the right way to give advice.

Phil Krahn, B.Com.
Founder & Principal
25+ years in finance, from night auditor to VP Finance to founding Big Country Accounting Group. Serving businesses and families across Alberta, Saskatchewan, and British Columbia.
Questions about your own situation?
General writing only goes so far. Thirty minutes on the phone is free, and you will get a straight answer about your actual circumstances.

